On an island of truth-tellers and liars, one islander says: 'I am a liar.' What is he?

You're a stranger on an island where every inhabitant is either a knight, who always tells the truth, or a knave, who always lies. One islander walks up and says, 'I am a knave.' Can you work out whether he's a knight or a knave?

Reveal the answer

Neither is possible — the statement traps both types in a contradiction. A knight would never falsely call himself a knave, since that would be a lie. A knave can never truthfully call himself a knave, since that would be the truth. No consistent islander could actually say this; it's a self-referential paradox in disguise, a simpler cousin of the Liar Paradox. Logician Raymond Smullyan built an entire genre of puzzles on this knight-and-knave premise in his 1978 book.

— Raymond Smullyan, What Is the Name of This Book? The Riddle of Dracula and Other Logical Puzzles — 1978

One credited idea per card. No filler. Swipe the rest in Savvy.

Keep swiping — it's free Works right in your browser. No app store needed.

More Puzzles

All Puzzles cards →
More from Raymond Smullyan →

Five ideas worth knowing, every week

The week's best cards and a puzzle, credited as always. Free, unsubscribe any time.